This site is under construction. Please pardon our appearance while we build Earthrise Commons, and feel free to follow along on GitHub!

Wicked Questions and Sustainability Writing Courses

Matthew Newcomb

SUNY New Palz

>

Short Lesson Plan

🔁This content is yours to use. Download it, remix it, adapt it, share it—make it work for your community. 

After reading the lesson plan, please refer to the bottom of the lesson plan for self-reflection questions to assist with your next steps!

Students will be able to:

Write effectively across multiple rhetorical contexts related to real-world sustainability issues, engage with complex and contested “wicked questions” that resist easy answers, and think critically about the nuances of negotiating a more sustainable world with others. Students will practice writing in the varied and difficult contexts around real-world sustainability issues. Students will reach these goals by working through varied readings, activities, and sub-questions scaffolded around a central sustainability theme. 

Rationale and Context

Writing courses centered on sustainability offer a powerful opportunity to engage students from a wide range of disciplines. By anchoring a course in a single compelling “wicked question,” one that is complex, contested, and unresolved, instructors can motivate students, foster interdisciplinary thinking, and make writing feel purposeful and relevant. 

This lesson plan template is designed to help instructors identify and develop their own big question. It encourages reflection on how others have approached sustainability-focused writing courses, and offers a framework for generating sub-questions, selecting readings, and designing activities that support student writing across multiple rhetorical contexts.

Learning Objectives & Goals

Primary Objective: Instructors will be able to choose a "big question" or focus for a writing class that incorporates complex and varied sustainability issues.

Reflective Practice: Instructors will reflect on big questions used by others and experiment with sub-questions and multi-disciplinary approaches to assess their options.

Purpose: To motivate students, practice the importance of writing across multiple contexts, and encourage complex thinking regarding sustainability.

Further Development (Next Steps for Instructors)

After a primary "wicked" question is chosen, faculty will need to develop a comprehensive syllabus of readings, activities, and support materials for their courses (see the example syllabus in the attached files).

Resources

Instructor Biography

Matthew Newcomb teaches rhetoric, writing, and literary theory at SUNY New Paltz, with a focus on argument, environmental writing, and science writing. He is a Sustainability Faculty Fellow and former writing program administrator.

Selected Publications:

Religion, Narrative, and the Environmental Humanities: Bridging the Rhetoric Gap (Routledge, 2023).

“Hurricane Style” in Departures in Critical Qualitative Research (2020).

“Fire Insurance: Evangelical Environmental Escapism” in ISLE (2018).

“Sustainability as a Design Principle for Composition” in CCC (2012).

SELF- REFLECTION: INVITATION FOR EDUCATORS:

1) Finding your “wicked question”

What sustainability issue do you find yourself returning to even outside of work? Could that unresolved tension become the anchor for a course?

Have you ever tried to write your way through a hard problem? What did that process teach you that you could not have learned just by reading or discussing it?

What is the difference between a question that is merely complicated and one that is truly “wicked?” How do you explain that distinction?

2) Writing as a tool

When you assign writing, are you primarily thinking about what students will produce, or about what they will work through in the process. How might shifting that emphasis change your prompts?

What kinds of writing do your students do outside your classroom? How might those rhetorical contexts be brought into conversation with more formal academic writing?

Do your current assignments ask students to write for someone? Where could a real or imagined audience make the stakes feel more genuine?

3) Sustainability across disciplines

Which disciplines outside your own do you feel at least equipped to bring into a sustainability conversation? What is one small step toward bridging that gap—a reading, guest speaker, a co-taught unit?

Your students arrive from wildly different majors and backgrounds. How might a shared “wicked question” surface unexpected expertise in the room, and how could you design space for that to happen?

How does sustainability show up in the form of your course, not just the content? Are there ways your syllabus, pacing, or workload could itself model more sustainable practices?